Hello dear
Welcome To Firefly Pizzeria
Firefly Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Grand Lake, Colorado, offers an authentic Italian dining experience that is not to be missed. Renowned for its wood-fired pizzas, each dish showcases the perfect balance of flavors, thanks to carefully sourced organic ingredients. Chef Mark Consiglio crafts fresh dough daily, ensuring an exceptional crust that elevates every bite. Customers rave about the Firefly special and the delightful gelato, particularly the pistachio flavor. The welcoming atmosphere, complete with outdoor patio seating, makes it ideal for a casual lunch or dinner. Firefly Pizzeria is a testament to culinary passion and tradition, promising satisfaction with each slice.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Firefly
Bianca
US$15.00Sasuage & Mushroom
US$20.00
Pepperoni
US$18.00Cherry Amarena
Chicago Pothole
Italian Vanilla
Double Chocolate
Cheese
US$15.00 About
Firefly Pizzeria
Welcome to Firefly Pizzeria, a gem nestled in the heart of Grand Lake, Colorado, located at 826 Grand Ave. Renowned for its authentic Italian pizzas and commitment to quality, this charming pizzeria brings a taste of Italy to the Rockies.
At Firefly Pizzeria, the culinary experience is elevated through the art of wood-fired cooking. The authentic wood-fired oven not only creates a delightful, smoky depth but also ensures the crust of every pizza is perfectly crisp and satisfying. Customers rave about the homemade feel of the pizza, with many noting the extraordinary flavor profiles crafted through locally sourced organic ingredients. As one enthusiast put it, “the art of getting the dough right is what makes a great pizza.”
Among the standout offerings is the Firefly special, praised for its enticing spice, alongside the classic Margherita and Carne pizzas, which are equally delectable. The reviews echo a strong sentiment – even those who typically shy away from pizza find themselves enamored with the culinary creations here. Chef Mark Consiglio’s daily ritual of making fresh dough complements the vibrant atmosphere that his family contributes to, enriching the dining experience with a sense of community.
No visit is complete without indulging in their gelato, specifically the Pistachio flavor, which has garnered enthusiastic recommendations from patrons. Perfect for a warm day in the picturesque surroundings of Grand Lake, the gelato is a testament to the pizzeria's commitment to authentic Italian delicacies.
Firefly Pizzeria is not just a place to eat; it’s an experience that engages the senses. Whether you're enjoying a quick lunch on the sunny patio or a cozy dinner with family, every bite reflects the dedication to quality and flavor. As recommended by repeat visitors, don’t miss out on this unique culinary destination – your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Authentic Italian and delicious pizzas. Do try their Gelatos; we loved their Pistachio Gelato. Highly recommend. ”
“ If you're in Grand Lake, Colorado, do yourself a favor and experience Firefly Pizza. Their dedication to organic ingredients is evident in every bite, delivering flavor profiles that are perfectly balanced and incredibly satisfying. As someone who usually steers clear of pizza, I'm genuinely hooked on their offerings. The authentic wood-fired oven gives their pizzas an unparalleled, amazing crust and smoky depth. ”
“ Loved this pizza place in Grand Lake! It was highly recommended so we tried it. We ate outside on the patio tables and there is a restroom nearby which was nice! The pizza was delicious! Everything tasted so good and homemade. The crust was delicious and wood fired. Loved it! Great for a quick lunch or dinner. ”
“ Amazing and traditional Italian style wood fired pizza! I took 4 teenagers and they all approved! The Firefly special was our favorite (spicy-so if you don’t like that-go for the Margarita or Carne which we also devoured!) and the gelato for dessert was very special! Chef Mark Consiglio makes the dough fresh in house every day and his lovely wife and kids run the store with him. My kids were in Italy earlier this year and they marked this pizza for authenticity on point, so don’t miss out!!! ”
“ Amazing elevated pizza! I am a pizza fanatic from Don Antonio’s in New York, and the famous Bianco’s in Phoenix, when I find a pizza like this being done with such perfection, I have to share it. The art of getting the dough right is what makes a great pizza. Add locally sourced ingredients, creative topping combinations from a chef who knows his art, and you have an elevated pizza. Cannot wait to return just to try every other pizza they have. ”
“ We were visiting the Rocky Mountain area in Colorado, when we stumbled upon Firefly Pizza. The restaurant is a family based restaurant offering fresh ingredients. The Neapolitan style pizza was excellent, it was a total 5/5 stars! ”
“ Some of my favorite pizza I've ever eaten. I got a pepperoni and it was perfect. The dough and crust is exactly what I'm looking for. Will definitely return every time I visit Grand Lake. ”
“ Delicious and fresh! The mushrooms I ordered for the Bianca pizza were great. I really liked the vibe. I hope to return next season and enjoy more of the menu and try some gelato. ”